Menu of Oyster Bar - New York in New York, USA

Menu Overview

Oyster Bar - New York, nestled on 77 Delancey St in the heart of the Lower East Side, lives up to its reputation as a quintessential oyster bar with a menu that both honors classic seafood traditions and delivers bold, memorable flavors. The highlight here is undeniably the raw oysters on the half shell, celebrated by patrons and critics alike. Their freshness is palpable—a briny, clean bite that speaks to quality sourcing and expert shucking. During happy hour, these oysters are a steal at just $1 each, making it an irresistible draw for oyster lovers, as several guests have attested to the experience being some of the best in the city.

Beyond the raw oysters, the Oyster Pan Roast stands out as a soulful dish. Rich and comforting, it is a showcase of seafood layered with a robust, savory broth that elevates the oysters’ natural flavors. This signature preparation reflects the bar’s ability to walk the line between simplicity and culinary depth, offering warmth and complexity in every spoonful.

The menu extends to other East Coast favorites such as the New England Clam Chowder, a creamy, hearty classic, and the New York Caesar Salad, which provides a fresh, crisp counterpoint to the richer offerings. These dishes complement the oysters and pan roast perfectly, creating a well-rounded taste experience rooted firmly in regional tradition.

Happy hour specials add more value and variety, featuring a pairing of martinis with a double cheeseburger at $20 on Mondays and Tuesdays, which invites a playful mix of casual and refined dining. Sundays bring pitchers of beer for $25, ideal for those looking to unwind with friends in an authentic Lower East Side atmosphere. The cocktail program, especially the Espresso Martini, receives high praise for its balance and punch, underscoring the bar’s commitment to excellence beyond seafood.

The ambience is electric yet intimate—low lighting and high spirits fill the room, making it an ideal spot for lively conversations or a memorable date night. Staff like Caroline and Tim enhance the experience with attentive service and vibrant personality, ensuring guests feel welcomed and cared for.

While most dishes excel in flavor and presentation, some menu items, like the fish tacos, may not hit the mark for everyone. Still, this minor shortcoming hardly detracts from the overall quality and appeal of the place.

In summary, Oyster Bar - New York offers a compelling seafood journey centered on expertly served raw oysters and hearty oyster pan roast. Its blend of classic East Coast flavors, exceptional happy hour deals, and warm, authentic atmosphere make it a must-visit for seafood enthusiasts and casual diners alike. Whether you come for oysters, cocktails, or just the vibe, this spot delivers a taste of New York's Lower East Side charm with every visit.